“The story is told of one luckless settler arriving in a pitiable state of exhaustion and dilapidation at the office of Donald A. Smith, M.P., in Winnipeg and proclaiming: “Well, look at me, ain’t I a healthy sight” I’ve come by the Government water route from Thunder Bay and it’s taken me twenty-five days to do it. During that time I’ve been half starved on victuals I wouldn’t give a [...]. The water used to pour into my bunk at night, and the boat was so leaky that every bit of baggage I’ve got is waterlogged and ruined. But that ain’t all. I’ve broke my arm and sprained my ankle helping to carry half a dozen trunks over a dozen portages, and when I refused to take a paddle in one of the boats, an Ottawa Irishman told me to go to hell and said that if I gave him any more damned chat he’d let me get off and walk to Winnipeg.”
An unhappy traveller
Source: Fritz, D. L. (1986, August 24). Special history study on the Dawson Trail and other routes relating to Voyageurs National Park, Minnesota (p.21). U.S. Department of the Interior, National Parks Service, Denver Service Center, Central Team. Denver, Colorado. Also Special history study on logging and lumbering as associated with the areas now in AC 16304. Retrieved June 3, 2020 from http://npshistory.com/publications/voya/dawson-trail-shs.pdf.
This man’s unhappy lament was repeated by numerous travelers. Others complained about the various station-masters as being “brutes” or “mean and surly”. The baggage handling frequently got low marks.
Another observer, who visited Prince Arthur’s landing on Thunder Bay saw American agents attempting to lure Canadian immigrants away from the Dawson Route, arguing that Minnesota and/or Dakota were more hospitable places.
Fritz, David L. (1986, August 24). Special history study on the Dawson Trail and other routes relating to Voyageurs National Park, Minnesota (P.20). U.S. Department of the Interior, National Parks Service, Denver Service Center, Central Team. Denver, Colorado. Also Special history study on logging and lumbering as associated with the areas now in AC 16304. Retrieved June 3, 2020 from http://npshistory.com/publications/voya/dawson-trail-shs.pdf.
“The place has been known by the immigrants who passed over the Dawson route as “Hungry Hall”.” Source: The Manitoban : [Vol. 1, no. 6 (May 1892)]. Retrieved from https://www.canadiana.ca/view/oocihm.8_06661_6/13?r=0&s=1
Emigrants had to bring their own provisions and because trips often took longer than expected, it was not unusual for travellers to arrive at the N.W. Angle starving. Soon it came to be known as “Hungry Hall” Source: Grant, George Monro (1835-1902). (1873). Ocean to ocean: Sandford Fleming’s expedition through Canada in 1872 (P.96). Being a diary kept during a journey from the Atlantic to the Pacific with the expedition of the engineer-in-chief of the Canadian Pacific and Intercolonial railways. With sixty illustrations. BC Historical Books. Diaries. Retrieved June 3, 2020, from https://open.library.ubc.ca/collections/bcbooks/items/1.0221770
Back to Brokenhead River Crossing Heritage Tour page | Top
Previous page: Forest Fire of 1897
Next page: Harrison Creek: Gateway to Manitoba